Or “the agony of defeat” --it being Olympics time, and that old USA
t.v. sports slogan (Wide World of Sports) comes to mind.
[… HERE; but sympathies to the tragedy in Vancouver]
I was trying to put things in perspective. We live in an age when, to the vast majority of mankind (or at least the vast majority of the teeny percentage of those I can attest to), knot tying is the thing one does when one doesn't have velcro, bungie cords, or ratched webbing straps handy. What I was saying is that the period when a man's life and livelihood depended on knot craft are waning. Sure, there are still fishermen, lobstermen, and such, but they are fewer and fewer. And their rigging is less and less knot dependent.
I don’t swallow that thought about “someone must’ve done it before”.
Yes, history grows long; but in today’s world one might see burgeoning
(over)population as a sort of lateral like growth and yet I don’t see
evidence of the knotting variety one posits for historical mankind either
in what extant documentation et cetera might reveal it or in today’s
knotting. As for the numbers of commercial fishermen, is that for
absolute or proportional numbers? I suppose you might be right,
for technology helps them to be all the more pro(DEs?)tructive,
but certainly the population to consume product is vastly larger.
But I think that they are still highly cordage- & knotting-dependent.
One case where a knot has lost to a device is the cod-end knot,
which is a pity if it is widespread, for there were some nifty
tangles put to that task, some like no other knots!
Another attribute shows up, too, to give some caution to assuming
all has been already done: lack of imagination and adherence to
standard practice. I’ve done a fair bit of gandering commercial-fishing
knotting --and highly recommend it, btw–, and the variety while quite
interesting is hardly so great as to lead me to conclude that all has
been discovered. And there are some to-me-obvious things that I’ve
yet to find. But my scope of looking is pretty small. Sadly, though,
it seems that most others aren’t even looking! – except in books,
or on-line in the land of echoes & myths.
Beyond this is the issue of materials : one needn’t go far
back in history to leave the age of synthetic cordage, and IMO
that implies a narrower set of needs for knotting. I cannot imagine
anyone in history fiddling the Bimini Twist (an angling knot intended
for use in modern cordage), to cite one example.
But...I am still thrilled to discover ([i]re[/i]or otherwise) a "new" knot.
btw, you got me thinking of the time I "discovered" that a Sheet bend was a Bowline with the loop cut. :D Another First! ;D Then along came Ashley :(
It can be of interest what path led you to some knot.
I can recall seeing the bowline & sheet bend in [u]Chapman’s
Piloting Guide (which I today bought a '66 edition of), but NOT
of realizing their resemblance; the Sheet bend stuck with me (though
at the time I had no interest in knots), and the Bowline I don’t much
recall even mastering (!).
Here's the diagram... which, I believe, is exactly what Dan was saying. Dan?
BINGO! – though it took some tying and reorienting to see this.
I find it grips well enough in the sisal the scouts use.
– a key aspect to knots: material (and use/force). I don’t think it works
so well in synthetic rope, and wouldn’t trust it for much. (So, your Scouts
are using sisal? It was Surrey scouts’ venture into synthetics that led to
the “Surrey Six” suggested alternatives to traditional scouting knots.)
–dl*