The Knot Drawing (cypher) utility continues to be enhanced and is now becoming a handy sketching and editing tool, this aspect seems to be eclipsing its initial design function as a means to create and exchange small, reliable text based knot files. Already the list of proposed enhancements for Version 5 includes - adjustable cord thickness, Copy/Paste, Drag/Drop, Zoom, Multiple tabbed drawing grids and rigid Spar elements; all very much aimed at making a more usable knot drawing tool, the cypher bit was fun but seems not as useful as the drawing functionality.
And when you use the utility, you start to understand why. Creating a knot diagram by pen and paper can quickly become untidy as you realise that bits are heading in the wrong direction or you have not left enough space. With the drawing utility, change is easy and relatively fast and can quickly lead to experimentation with the knot structure. This in turn leads inexorably to the topic so often raised amongst knotters - Just what is it that makes a knot work? which, after a significant preamble, brings me around to the gist of the subject line -“For What is a Knot??”
The following blue diagrams show the evolution of twists and turns from a straight cord to something which looks much like the OH knot.
https://knotcyphers.pbwiki.com/f/OH%20sequence.jpg
Except that in the red OH knot, just one junction has been transposed (shown in green) from the blue close equivalent.
One transposition from ‘over’ to ‘under’ makes a round turn into the familiar Overhand Knot.
What has changed in this simple example? If we ‘pull’ on the blue Round Turn, nothing is obstructed and the turn simply straightens out and the structure falls apart. But in the red OH knot, every loop is locked against another by crossing it from above to below (or v.v.), so it cannot flow unobstructed.
So could we define a knot as ‘A LOCKED CORD STRUCTURE’ ? or perhaps ‘A SELF LOCKED CORD STRUCTURE’ ?
Can we identify these locking structures and describe a knot with them? Can we start to describe what a knot is by describing its active components?
Derek