hello,
I came across a photograph of the fixed knot used by the Hammar company in its H20 security equipment http://www.cmhammar.com/products/h20-for-liferafts/h20-solas-model/. I am puzzled by the knot they use for tying the loop and have been unable to identify it.
(this item and similar ones are illustrated elsewhere on the Hammar site, but I did not find any closer view of the knot itself)
Can some sharp-eyed knot expert identify this knot?
I downloaded the .pdf manual, used the magnifier function and it really looks like the Overhand follow through bend (Water knot, Tape knot, Ring bend, Grass knot) to me.
I have tied it and compared and that’s my take.
Would seem to be a good enough choice for the product.
allow me to challenge your suggestion, as, for me, the overall shape of the knots differ: the knot pictured in Hammar’s docs looks more ‘barrel-like’, i.e. more turns, loops, etc. in the middle part than at the end parts of the finished knot. On the contrary, derivatives of the overhand knot have a more ‘spherical’ look. (sorry for this very inaccurate wording)
Challenges accepted, that’s how we can learn.
Please tie what I came up with, dress and tighten it as much as you can and hold it next to the attached picture.
Looks more like a Fisherman’s knot to me - the 2 wraps running parallel don’t seem to be from the Water Knot (where there would be 2 pairs of wraps) but they do match a Fisherman’s very closely.
Freshly tied Overhand Follow Through Bend (attached picture) and it does look very similar.
The Fisherman’s Knot looks almost identical when held a certain way.
I chose the more secure knot (imo) given the application and appearance.
Now if we could see the other side in the OP’s request for identification, that would clear it up definitively. I did what I could to enlarge and clarify the pictures of on the website, but could not get clear results.
In fact it is difficult to distinguish the two bends if viewed from a certain angle, but the image included in the page indicated by jnimo(http://www.cmhammar.com/products/h20-for-liferafts/h20-solas-model/ ) , although not very clear, seems to show the other side of the questioned knot, revealing(in a foggy way) the shape of the"backview"of a Fisherman’s knot(IMO):
Capturing the image from the page you’ve linked to Luca, doing what I can to enhance it, it does look similar to the fisherman’s knot. Not conclusively though.
I cannot orient all the parts, right handed vs. left handed, reversed images, etc., to produce the website’s posted pictures.
The curves and tails just don’t match.
It seems fair to say that is knot is either the Water Knot or Fisherman’s Knot but we need a rear view to be sure which it is. The attached (not very good!) pic of a Fisherman’s Knot shows that it can be made to look like the website picture though I had to tie the opposite way round to the way I would normally do it.
My opinion has changed to it being the Fisherman’s knot because I have retied it a couple of more times now, both versions, re-enhanced the photo again and it was the last attempt with extreme tightening with very short tails that allowed it to take the exact shapes/configuration.
Using 6mm cord and applying near three hundred pounds of tension finally caused the very short end to rotate forward towards me as in the company’s photo.
I read your reply #7 just before having to leave home, I had just the time to replicate the knot in the Hammar page, convincing myself that it was a Fisherman’s, but at the same time noting the incongruities you mentioned, so I left home mulling about;now that I’m back I see that you have solved the “mystery.” At this point I can only thank you(and.. please, be careful to not break your nails!).
I concur in the identification of the questioned knot
as the i fisherman’s knot[/i] --the irregular bulge
on the right side accents the area where the “spines”
of the overhand components abut each other
(given that it is a concordant not discordant version
of this knot --i.e., same handedness for overhands).