Hitches on a bight

I’m looking for suggestions of hitches on a bight. The situation occurs when there’s far too much line to pass the end around the object. For example, tying a boat to a tree or post at short distance, when the excess line length could be 50ft or more.

I like the pile hitch for this reason, however it’s not always possible to drop a bight over the top. I’ve tried varieties of timber hitches on a bight and picket-line hitch on a bight, however I’d like a non-snug type hitch. It can be cumbersome to tuck under snugged parts against an object, especially quickly and under some load. Bunt-line on a bight seems to have potential.

I found ABOK #1810, High Post hitch on a bight, which could be useful for a slipped solution. A simpler non-slipped solution would be nice to have, though.

I’d like to hear what others have in mind.

How about tying a regular bowline, but use a bight instead of working end?

Certainly a solution and one I’ve no doubt employed at one time or another. I’m curious if there is a purpose made hitch for this, or a more suitable knot to modify to work in this way. The picket-line hitch comes out really nice on a bight.

I’ve never been able to get the high post on a bight (ABOK 1810) to consistently come out cleanly, otherwise this would be very close to what I am after, aside from it being slipped. I also find it strange there’s not many hitches on a bight in the ABOK.

The hardest part of your request is the ability to tie this under load. Otherwise, you’d have lots of options. What kind of load are you expecting?

Ok, tying under load ???

Then you may consider using a Gnat Hitch. You don’t need to move the standing end. It will slip some length of course.

“Under load” is probably an over statement by most standards, but load nonetheless. I’m not sure how to best quantify the load, a small-medium sized boat in a stiff breeze is a fair example (the last situation I encountered, in less than ideal circumstances). Enough to keep the standing end taut through tying, to the point where tucking the end through a snug type hitch would be somewhat difficult or might get a finger pinched.

I lack the terminology to describe how the standing end gains length/slips/is loosened when the hitch is tightened, this would be undesirable. The gnat hitch is simple, but this would be slipped when tied on a bight, correct?

The simplest thing is to tie off not with a “hitch”
–technically, biding around some object–
but a “noose” (where one is surrounding the
anchor’d-to object and hitching rope to rope)
–to be pedantic about it all,
but a worthwhile distinction, IMO. :wink:
And your “not a snug hitch” I think says just
as much.

And the simplest, most obvious(?) tying would
be a taut-line hitch --a rolling hitch of the
rope to itself, i.e.. So, you’d bring around enough
material in the bight to do this, working with the
loaded side of the bight and just nudging the
mirroring other side’s material out of your way,
until it’s unavoidably brought through the closing
Ihitch[/I],
which bight tip then would be well secured by
tying off with a slip knot stopper (the loaded
side making the overhand and the other the
slipping part.
(Essentially, your result is this : a slipped & stopped
taut-line hitch with a lonnnng tail that mimics all
the turns of the hitch, but well clear of that --you are
NOT working with bight legs together.
And this can be tied under serious load.
(I have no idea why the gnat hitch is suggested.
(Well, I have an idea, but … .) ) )

–dl*

Why not 2 half hitches (with or without round turn)? Can be tied under load, so it avoids ending up with slack in the standing part. And you can easily tie the whole knot with the bight, so it’s not slipped.

Edit: this youtube video shows it (with 3 half hitches)

I do agree with Tom_Zal on this one. Just keep it simple.

Would someone please sketch a diagram of this situation so we landlubbers can follow it in three dimensions?

Since the original poster is away from the end of the rope, he’s looking for something tied on the bight. For a general, simple example, you can look at a timber hitch on the bight which treats a bight of rope like the end of a line (second diagram):

http://notableknotindex.webs.com/timberhitch.html

But since the tyer may be dealing with some load during tying, a similar approach with a round turn and two half hitches has been suggested to diminish the load during the final tucks:

http://notableknotindex.webs.com/roundturntwohalfhitches.html