I was looking online on how to tie these two knots. I saw pictures of the starting position for the hunter’s bend. It appeared that it can be tied in which you start out in a similar manner to shake hands. http://www.layhands.com/knots/Knots_Bends.htm (for the hunter’s, can’t find an image for shake hands) Now looking at the starting positions of the two knots (one end looks like a “b” and the other end looks like a “d”) It appears the only difference between the hunters bend and the shake hands bend is that the part where the bights interlock is reversed.
Is that really the only difference between the two knots? It seems that the tying process is the same for both too.
Welcome, myoman!
You’re right that the Shakehands is similar to SmitHunter’s, and I think you pretty
much see the difference: in the starting position presented by Dave Root’s “Layhands”
site, one can reverse either the 3r crossing (i.e., where each end crosses its own SPart)
or the 1st two, where the SParts interlock. There is some further chance of variation in
the tucking of the ends, as both knots have a couple ways to go (and in fact SmitHunter’s
is known in the inferior tucking, IMO, to that in which the ends more wrap each other).
As for the tying process, I always tie these interlocked-Overhands bends by tying one
Overhand and then reeving the other rope through this according to which knot I want.
–dl*
H Asher’s notation for the two knots is:
Hunter-Smith (Riggers): RR, Up-Opp; U&D Centre
Shakehands: RR, Down-Opp; U&D Centre, Cross South
In Miles Symmetric Bends book, Hunters’ is #B9, Shakehands #B10, though he does not try to link the two in his notes.
Since I use Shakeshands more for a loop than a pure bend, I use the follow through approach in tying it.
paulj
I mentioned in my earlier Shake Hands thread that the loops can interlock in two ways. In Asher’s version, the overhand loop for line A is closer to the standing end of line A. In Ashley’s version(s), used to make loops, the overhand loop is closer to the working end. Another way to put it, Ashley’s version interchanges the working and standing ends. Ashley’s version cannot, as far as I can tell, be tied by starting with interlocking loops.
paulj
Hi Myoman,
Ho Hum – you’re hooked – welcome to the club and to Pandora’s amazing box of string things.
So many knots start with a similar tying method, so many look so alike, yet one tiny exchange can transform a Jeckyll into a Hyde. With the double overhand ‘family’ of knots you are faced with so much potential for variation in how to arrange two overhands to lay or enmesh with one another that within that family you can range from the ‘Queen of knots’ the Alpine butterfly , through many many variants such as the ones you have found intrigue with, right down to a lethal ‘cogging’ variant that I doubt even has a name. Two knots, four ends and so many variants I am sure you could spend a large part of your life mapping and researching just this one family.
It can be a worry when two knots look alike and are tied in a similar manner, it is easy to mix up the methods and therefore the knots, perhaps with serious consequences. For example take the Alpine and the Middlemans - do you fold before you twist or twist before you fold?
As for the b and d method of tying the two knots that have sparked your interest - easy to get one instead of the other. You ask “are they the same except for the orientation”, well yes and no. While it is the only structural difference, the two knots dress up very differently and we can assume they will behave in a manner peculiar to their dressing. Even the difference of changing the loading point as in the Asher version of Shake Hands vs the Ashley version (a decorative knot #1035), possibly the #1035 variant of loading the opposite OH knot would exhibit greater strength and stability, so changing the structure as the two knots which grabbed your attention could also have a marked effect.
Do you have any thoughts about when and why one would be ‘better’ or ‘worse’ than the other?