New thread topic started because it was derailing Alan Lee’s work.
It follows from this thread: https://igkt.net/sm/index.php?topic=6451.msg43386#msg43386
This line of argument is in relation to illustrations #1057 and #1058 in ‘ABoK’ (published by Clifford Ashley in 1944)…
Quote from: agent_smith on August 11, 2019, 02:27:45 AMThe following comments are potentially off-topic but are in direct response to Dan Lehman at reply #10... per [b]Dan Lehman[/b] at reply #10 in relation to #1057 and #1058: Quote Hardly such an oversight, IMO. Rather, he simply wasn't playing the game you're so hard at in narrowly/strictly per-your-own-definition identifying *bowlines*; and in these, he felt some merit. An interesting comment that I just noticed... possibly either a cryptic reply or an exercise in obfuscation? You might do better to just write in clear and unambiguous language if you believe #1057 and/or #1058 to be deserving of the title 'Bowline'.The language is perspicuous, but you insist on a perverted reading.
YOU are all gung-ho about YOUR notion of “bowline”; Ashley, I surmise,
was less so --and he offered that these cited knots “had a better claim”
to “bowline” --for which HE does NOT give a set of criteria. YOU impose
yours, and then call Ashley mistaken : heckuva way to run a contest! :o :
I do not insist on any ‘perverted’ reading of ABoK.
And I am not Gung ho about my understanding of what defines a ‘Bowline’!
Rather - I have presented a robust theoretical analysis which does withstand close scrutiny.
In terms of Ashley being mistaken… is this such a far-fetched proposition?
Even highly trained pilots can make mistakes.
I note that even NASA managed to destroy two space shuttles - which - when you go back and look at the accident reports, is astonishing in terms of how NASA could have prevented them from occurring.
I would also comment that there are numerous typo errors and other conceptual errors in Ashley’s book.
You yourself have attempted to compile a list of all the errors - which are not insignificant.
In theorizing that Ashley either made a simple mistake or that #1057/58 somehow escaped his proof reading - this is in no way denigrating Ashley or declaring him to be deficient.
People make mistakes - and one must also consider that ‘ABoK’ was published at a time before the digital age and computers.
There are several thousand illustrations and in my mind - it is not a far-fetched concept that errors may have slipped through the proof reading phase.
Even in the digital age - errors still (frequently) occur in published works.
#1057/58 are anomalies - in that they have a geometry that is completely removed from all of the other ‘Bowlines’ illustrated in his book.
Without exception, all of the primary/first order ‘Bowlines’ presented in his book have a clear and unambiguous nipping loop and a bight structure (which consists of a collar that performs a U turn around the SPart).
Indeed, all of the nipping loops he illustrates are ‘TIB’ and take the form of a simple helical loop (or double loop per #1013).
For example, an eye knot based on #46 (simple overhand knot) must be excluded from the title of ‘Bowline’ on account of the nipping structure being non TIB.
And this is one of the reasons for requiring the characteristic of ‘TIB’ - it acts as a filter against an entire cohort of eye knots that might otherwise be regarded as being ‘Bowlines’.
I am happy to debate the following salient points with you:
- That Ashley was not infallible - he could conceivably make mistakes.
- That errors may have slipped through his proof reading - and gone to print without him realizing (until too late).
- That he published his book in an era where computers did not exist - and everything had to be done tediously by hand and eye.
- That #1057/58 could have escaped his detection and gone to print before he realized the error.
- That #1057/58 have a geometry that is completely different to all of the other ‘Bowlines’ depicted in his book.



