Recently I visited the workshop of an art master blacksmith. On the wall she (yes, this smith is a she ;): http://www.smedjatherese.se) had a quote from her father, also a master blacksmith.
It said (translation not exactly verbatim):
You are not forging just because you beat up a piece of hot iron.
It is not really forging until the result looks as if you have made love to the material.
I realized this is true for most crafts/arts!
It is not knotting just because you tangle up a bunch of cords, either! Or, for that matter, if you make something and try to cram into it just about every decorative knot you have ever learned or read about. (I have seen bellropes made according to that principle. Just hideous!
http://www.langkawi.dk/smileys/s19.gif
)
It is true knotting when the energy you put into your technical skills and the emotional energy you put into the work balance each other. Then, and only then, you make something that you can look at and feel that there is really no other way it can properly look. It is just right.
It looks as if you have made love to the material.
All this may sound a bit Zen and the art of knotting, but I believe that there is something to it. The best things I have made have been those where I have been mentally, technically and emotionally focused on the work.
Or… what do you say?
Lasse C