Inline/directional Figure 8 as a bend

Anyone have any thoughts on the inline/directional figure 8 for use as a bend? I don’t think I even need to post instructions or pictures beyond: tie an inline/directional figure 8 and cut the loop, then reverse engineer. I have been tying it as a bend today, and it is pretty simple and one dressing reminds me of a snail.

My initial thoughts are it works very well as a bend, cinching up tight, then when the ends are pulled “against the grain”, it loosens right up. This possible disadvantage for the loop might be a huge advantage for the bend.

Anyone have any practical experience? Any particular version work better than another, or worse?

Yes, if the free ends get snagged in the wrong direction, the bend is toast. This problem would keep such a bend from any serious use.

It’s often called a “square / reef knot” and the parrots
all squawk that it’s not (or should not be used as) an end-2-end
joint.

Or, if you meant to “cut the loop” and load the appropriate
former eye leg qua opposing end, then that’s a thief knot
–even less well regarded as an end-2-end knot (but both
this and above will have the extra wrap & tuck of one
side’s tail.

–dl*

I’m confused. How does an inline Fig 8 bend become a Square? Now, we need a pic. There has got to be a link you can find quickly.

Am I sniffing some misunderstanding here?

If I got it right, the “in line” fig 8 bend is what I would rather call a re-threaded fig 8 bend, where first one line is loosely tied as a fig 8 stopper, then the other threaded back along the first, effectively doubling it, and the lines both have their standing part along with the working end of the other.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w6x-TK6L2Tk

The loop is tied in the same way, only that the “second line” then is the end of the first, when doubled back onto itself.

I don’t use it as I have other preferred knots. My “most” used bend, when I need a secure bend, is the Carrick Bend, which is much easier to tie and untie. (The citation marks because it isn’t more than something like a few times a year I would need a bend.)

Which one ? :slight_smile: There are two Carrick bends - depending on the way the tails are crossed before they exit the knot s nub. They may look very similar, but structurally they behave differently, and this becomes evident under heavy loading. See (1)

  1. http://igkt.net/sm/index.php?topic=4128

Here it is:
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flemish_bend

It loosens if you’re dealing with amateur level loads. I just got done testing an inline Fig 8 in paracord with a moderate load. The knot is basically a rock. I’m surprised and mildly peaved that nobody checked your statement there before I jammed this knot. There are plenty of others bends that are easier to tie and will not seize up like this. I see this knot as being useful where someone is not 100% sure how to tie others bends that are better in every way.

I think it is irrelevant to the discussion of the flemish/fig8/inline etc, but to clarify, the Carrick bend will as it seems not take the X form unless you help it to cross the ends. The ends when using the method I have outlined, don’t cross. Structurally it becomes somewhat different, but any of the two variations is amply secure, although the X one may need somewhat rougher handling to undo, as it seems to become firmer under heavy load. In most materials they hold until they break under load, and both can be undone after heavy load. I have not yet seen it take the X form spontaneously.

http://web.comhem.se/~u77479609/Carrick%20Bend.html

Under load, the X form actually can take another form than the initial one, as the two ends twist around each other when it is loaded. When a somewhat loosely tied X bend is exposed to repetitive jerks, it is likely to take the non-X form. “Somewhat loosely” could be interpreted as “with any elasticity”. Tied in bungee, it inevitably takes the non-X form even if at first X-ed, and I expect it to take that form under heavy load with most ropes. (Note that it is not secure in bungee, it will only hold for a constant load.)

So, I don’t tie the X form, and I doubt it will form spontaneously or can be done by accident.

I use a bend often for lanyards and for holding keys (I prefer dress shoe laces over metal key rings). OK, it’s technically not a bend, but the principle is about exactly the same. So, let’s just call it a bend. For these applications, I usually use a Butterfly Bend or a Carrick Bend because of the way the working ends for both knots exit out one side. Interestingly, a Zeppelin Bend is unsuitable for my needs here.

I didn’t think that this would cause such misunderstandings!

  1. The “inline / directional fig.8” is an eye knot and distinguished
    from the more common fig.8 with a bight in that the knot
    is seen as existing along a line of tension which is
    possibly (also) loaded end-2-end --it’s embedded, “inline”–;
    it is also “directional” in contrast to e.g. the butterfly which
    is used w/o regard to orientation of loading (though it
    is also asymmetric). Hence the OP’s mention of cutting the eye.

  2. And if one examines the parts in tension when loaded
    only end-2-end, it has similarly to the square /reef knot.

(Perhaps, knowing this, Knot4U can try another method of
untying his jammed-in-paracord knot --i.p., pulling the eye
and eye-side end apart, to capsize the knot!? YMMV.

–dl*

I would try if I knew what the heck we’re talking about. I provided a pic because nobody else has. If that pic is wrong, then please provide a correct pic. The knot may be obvious to some people here, but it’s not to me. Additional word descriptions will be 1,000 less effective than a pic.

Thanks

That is correct - I believe that is why it is not well known ( I myself had not recognized it as a variation of the Carrick bend, until this was pointed to me by Luca…)

I think that this is depending upon the stiffness of the rope - with stiff enough climbing ropes, the X-ed tails will retain their orientation and they will not be un-crossed by themselves, so the X-form will remain X-ed, just as the non-X-ed form remains non-X-ed. Of course, it also depends on how much loosely tied the initial form would be…

And a pic of the fig.8 end-2-end knot, yet the OP clearly
cites another : why didn’t you get (from the same source,
even) the right one? Grog’s Animated Knots has it, too,
among many sites.

–dl*

Well, I see no citation or link in the OP. So, we continue to have no pic. I have tied what I think the OP is describing, but it performs so badly that I figured he has to mean something else.

Cool thread LOL

… the OP and the thread very title read “Inline/Directional Figure 8”
and, alas, I guess it bears repeating (but requires comprehension)

::slight_smile:

Cool, thank you for the non-help.

Perhaps the OP means a directional figure eight loop as in the picture of this link. But tied as a bend (loop cut).
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Directional_figure_8_knot_Loop_Down.svg

It makes a neat compact bend with the tails lying alongside one of the ropes. Easy enough to tie and untie.

Hope this helps someone.

SS