I concur with Dan Lehman’s words of wisdom here…
Any post that has climbing tie-in knots as the subject matter seem to receive a lot of attention - some of it bordering on hysteria.
Knots don’t kill people - people kill people (this phrase also encompasses human error).
You dont need a licence to go rock climbing or mountaineering…but, you need a licence to drive a vehicle or to go parachuting, or to go scuba diving.
Ignorance is a wonderful thing - I mean, you can happily go and buy climbing equipment, read a few books (or read some confused posts on some climbing forum) and then go and try climbing/abseiling (rappelling for you Americans).
Death is lurking just around the corner.
So the Bowline…hmmm. Bowlines don’t kill people. Is it the gun that kills people, or is it the trigger puller? One thing for sure, history seems to repeat itself. That is, we will never 100% eliminate risk from any sports that involve exposure to falls from height. You cant have a 100% risk-free climbing experience. Maybe indoor climbing on artificial surfaces using an automatic (non-human) belay system with triple-action auto-locking captive-eye connector to harness might come the closest to eliminating (but not completely) risk.
So back to the bowline - it has no conscience - it is not self-aware. It is created by a human using knowledge and skill. The original inventor/discoverer of the Bowline (ABoK #1010) probably did not intend it to be used for climbing applications. It was probably first used in nautical/sailing applications.
At some point in history, climbers must have decided to use it (the Bowline) for their purposes. In the ‘good-old-days’, there was no such thing as an indoor climbing gym for the masses - and climbing was a ‘hard-man’ sport which required a certain level of commitment and devotion. Arguably, climbers of yesteryear were a hardier breed and more committed to the sport (it wasn’t just a fly-by-night new fad Y generation thing to try).
Have a look at some of the historic photos of Sir Edmund Hillary and also some books from Royal Robins - you’ll see the bowline featured as a prominent tie-in knot. These guys knew that #1010 in its original form needed to be ‘secured’ in some fashion to prevent it from working itself loose.
Access to the sport of climbing and mountaineering is a lot easier these days - like I said, you can buy gear and off you go - its a free world. Ignorance is bliss. Many people get introduced to climbing via the indoor (artificial) gym - and then they might attempt a quick transition to the real thing outdoors. When I started climbing (ie me, Mark) - there was no such thing as an indoor artificial climbing gym. My apprenticeship was done by climbing as a ‘second’ (I belayed the ‘lead’ climber - and then followed and ‘cleaned’ the route). I did this over many many months of concentrated commitment. This apprenticeship really worked for me - I developed really solid skills.
The pendulum has swung with tie-in knots over the decades… it started with the Bowline in the early pioneering days - then it evolved to ABoK #1047 and then, as ropes became thinner and thinner and sport climbing ethics were introduced, the pendulum swung back again toward the Bowline (#1010). We all know that you need to modify #1010 in some way to render it secure and stable. Right now, there are as many opinions as there are climbers. Some swear by #1047, others swear by a secured form of #1010.
And knot strength absolutely has nothing to do with anything in climbing (its a myth - one for the myth busters). What matters most is security and stability.
And Dan Lehman will now be thinking - “stop driveling and get to the point”… my point is this: Bowlines don’t kill people. Poor knowledge and skill (ie incompetence) does a much better job than the Bowline!
You can die just as quickly with a poorly/incorrectly tied #1047. Heck, you can die quickly in a number of ways.
The truth is that the climbing forums are full of ignorance, inaccuracies, poorly conceived conclusions, and hearsay… “My instructor told me such and such, so it must be true…” Who told their instructor? And who told that instructors instructor?
If you want to use a Bowline (#1010), you had better get educated real fast and learn how to modify it so it becomes secure and stable. Fail to do this, and you stand a very good chance of going to heaven or hell.
Make your own evidence-based assessment - don’t just take some unknown persons word for it. Your tie-in knot must be proven to work in all possible loading profiles associated with climbing and falling.
You also need to have 100% flawless memory retention of how to tie the knot - error free.
Dan, how did I go?
Mark