I was going to add this notification onto the string but I feel that it might get lost among all the newer topics that are being put forth. So I do apologize for sneaking back into the top of the line-up. It’s just that I feel as though I’ve stumbled onto a knotting mystery that MUST be solved and I’m a dog with a bone!
I began this quest nearly a month ago. I have a little information (which I will share with you but perhaps we, as the Guild, need to apply some gentle pressure on those with the information if we are to solve this puzzle.
Let me begin by sharing with you what I have uncovered to date. The original lanyard, as told to me by the Scout Association, Gilwell Park, is 1 FATHOM long. Also I have a very old picture circa 1911, of a boy scout with lanyard. Due to the 11kb rule, I cannot post this picture however you can view it at, http://knotcanada.webs.com/apps/photos/ The sliding knot may be a TH but I’m not quite certain. Perhaps one of our members will be more comfortable in identifying this knot.
I still cannot find any reference to the stationary knot on which the knife or whistle is attached.
To date, I have approached The Scout Association who provided me with the info on the length and the picture from their archives. I have requested information from the British War Museum, the Canadian War Museum and the South African Boer War Museum, none of whom have replied. I spoke with the Director of History at the Royal Military College in Kingston, Ontario. He advised me that he was most interested in learning the outcome of my search because his late father was the Scout Commissioner for the province of Quebec and he had been a cub and scout. He did not have any information to provide other than my best bet probably would be within the uniform guidelines of the British or Canadian army at the time of the Boer War.
Currently I am awaiting a response from the Royal Canadian Mounted Police regarding the origins of the side arm lanyard that they wear with their red dress tunic.
Some readers might wonder how I got from the Boy Scouts to the Boer War and ended up with the R.C.M.P. Well, here?s the story (in part, so far):
Following the 217 day Siege at Mafking (Second Boer War- Oct 1899 to May 1900), Colonel Baden-Powell was assigned to form a ?Policing force?. This group was paramilitary in nature and was named the South African Constabulary. Many of the men who served on this force were former Canadian military men who still wore their Stetson head gear. This is the same kind of hat worn by the Mounties today. It has been suggested that B.P. borrowed the dress from the South African Constabulary as the template for the scout uniform. This hypothesis seems sound since it is well documented that B.P. liked the Canadians Stetson hat and chose this as the official boy scout head gear. Due to Canada?s British Empire ties, it?s probably safe to assume that most British regulations regarding uniform code would apply.
More so in the case of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. This police force was assembled, much in the same way as the South African Constabulary, to bring law and order to a fledgling country. It started out with British/Canadian troops wearing the traditional red tunics and pill box hats of the day. This force became known as the North West Mounted Police. Although the pill box hats were replaced by the Stetson, the present day Mounties still wear the traditional red tunics as their dress uniform. If the lanyard (still worn today) followed the tradition of the vintage tunics, it is very possible that this is the same lanyard style adopted by B.P. for the scout uniform.
If you don?t agree with my thought process so far, please feel free to share your ideas.
Some might think that this is a lot of effort for a simple lanyard but I believe that I?m just following our basic philosophy of not allowing knotting to fade away into history. But just as important, the scout lanyard (although always an optional adornment) is an interesting piece of scouting history.
I truly believe that this knowledge needs to be unearthed and shared with the members of the Guild and all present and future Scouters
If anyone is as intrigued as I, please send off an email to the British War Museum archivist and request that they blow off the dust and help us to solve the lanyard mystery.
Information still needed: Knots used, original material (cotton, flax etc), cord thickness
John Staley
Keep at it John!
While I don’t have anything to contribute to your search, I do think you’re right in that what you’re doing is helping to prevent the loss of history. I certainly hope your able to find more information to share.