What is Flemish about the Flemish knot?

Hey all.

As you know the figure8 knot is also called a Flemish knot, do you guys have any idea where that name comes from? Dutch sailors I suppose, but I can’t find any solid information about it. The names of knots and the stories behind them can be so interesting, “Thieves knot” being a fun example.

If you have some interesting knot names please share.

Have a good one, B

Hello baldv1n,

Thanks for your question:

As you know the figure8 knot is also called a Flemish knot, do you guys have any idea where that name comes from? Dutch sailors I suppose, but I can't find any solid information about it.
I presume you are referring to #1047? I own several historic and other well known knot books (eg from CL Day, Ashley, Harry Asher, History & Science of Knots, etc) - and none offer any answers to your specific question. Therefore - sorry - I cannot help you. In the fullness of time, others may weigh in with answers...so you might have to be patient. Although one could speculate that the Dutch or Belgium nationals may have commonly used the 'figure 8' knot (again, I presume you are referring to #1047 F8?).

Commentary:
I am also curious about the ‘anti-Bowlines’.
The anti version of the Simple (#1010) Bowline is not illustrated in Ashley Book of Knots (ABoK).
Some sources refer to it as a ‘Boas’ Bowline (refer ‘Knotting Matters’ #27, per Geoffrey Budworth).
Its also been known as a Cossack knot, Kalmyk (a slipped version) and Eskimo Bowline.

I think part of the issue is that the human race is large and spread out geographically.
Prior to the digital age, records were written in hard copy books, and journals, and also passed on by word-of-mouth.
Language differences and the fact that some cultures didn’t have a written form of their language meant that as their culture slowly died out, so did their knowledge of arts/crafts.
We find archeological evidence of past cultures/civilizations - and can only speculate…

Hey Smith, thank you for your answer!

I’m relatively new to the vast and interesting world of knots so please correct me if I’m wrong but it seems that the ABoK#570, #1411 and the #1047 (the fig8 knot, bend and loop) all have a Flemish connection, It probably started with the simple and elegant fig8 knot (#570) being called Flemish and because it is a “building block” in other knots the Flemish part lived on?

But like you say Smith, much knowledge is lost and about some things one can only speculate.. hopefully someone here has heard a story or has a theory=)


The anti-Bowlines are interesting, I saw a 2page pdf on paci.com.au by you. Are you collecting names of anti-Bowlines? At first the word anti nudges you a bit because if feels like against or “that which seeks to eliminate X” but it is an appropriate term meaning the opposite of. Mirroring-bowlines also sounds good (and calmer) but it does perhaps not fully describe the concept.


All the best, B

Somewhere I read that many of the “national” names for knots came from sailors. If they learned a knot from another sailor (and they may not have spoken a common language), then they may have attributed the knot to the nationality of that sailor (or the ship he was on). Ashley hints at this on page 3.

Very little nationalism is evident among knots. One reason for this
may be that the merchant sailor has never been too particular about
what flag he sailed under, and in the general shifting about, knots soon
became common property. Here and there we have a “SPANISH,”
“PORTUGUESE,” “ENGLISH,” “FRENCH,” or “AMERICAN” KNOT, but
seldom is the application of such a name at all universal. The same
knot may be attributed to several countries, just as FLAT “OVER-ONEAND-
UNDER-ONE” SINNET (#2976) is called by English-speaking
sailors “FRENCH SINNET” and by the ever-polite French "TRESSE
ANGLAISE. "

When a national name is used as the primary name in a very influential book (such as Ashley’s), it tends to lock it in. The fact that Ashley lists “Flemish” but makes in a secondary name for the Figure Eight might mean he believes less in any true national origin.

Before this gets into a speculative spiral,
let me say that IIRC the BWLs article of PACI
has it pretty right :: I coined the term to mean

eye-knots w/nipping turn where returning eye leg
enters this turn from the side opposite to what
is done in #1010 (or side w/outgoing eye leg
on near side of crossing point)<<
–with my motivation coming from “anti-cyclone” being
the reverse rotation to a “cyclone” (and not calm air!).

But, now, regarding the more prominent sense of “anti”
as you remark, I use the term “backside” : the Myrtle
is a frontside BWL, and make the returning eye leg
insertion in the opposite direction, from the opp. side,
one has what has been called “bollard loop”, “Swedish
BWL” (allegedly per a KMatters article/letter(s)), which
is a backside BWL.

–dl*